Who Is "A"

We don't mean to be the bearer of pessimistic speculation, but we're worried about Toby's (Keegan Allen) loyalties in Season 4. Pretty Little Liars producer and writer Oliver Goldstick said that Toby would be “sucked back into the vortex of ‘A’” in the upcoming season. Here are five reasons we think Toby might join the “A” Team for real:

The Mom Connection

...

There aren’t many who have avoided becoming a target of “A”’s schemes on Pretty Little Liars, but they do exist. Which Rosewood residents have largely stayed off of “A's" radar, and what does that say about their chances of being the mysterious villain herself?

Ella Montgomery

Ella Montgomery (Holly Marie-Combs) has been collateral damage or has been used as an...

It’s getting hard to keep track of all the clandestine groups running around Rosewood. First, there was only “A” (those were the days). Now, we have the “A” Team (Mona, Toby, and Spencer captained by Red Coat) and the “B” Team (Melissa, Jenna, Shana, and possibly Wilden) to worry about!

Are the “A” Team and “B” Team working...

When it comes down to it, we lump any Rosewood residents between the ages of 19-25 into one quasi-villainous category. They could be suspects. They could be victims. They’re probably both. That’s just how it is. Which is why we were only sort of surprised to find out that Wilden seems to be connected with Melissa, Jenna, and Shana — the team we now collectively refer to as...

So, you’re still dying to know who else is on the “A” team on Pretty Little Liars. Don’t worry — we’ve got our crack team of sleuths on the case, analyzing every clue for your mystery-solving pleasure. The Season 3 finale promised us a Big “A” reveal — however, now we have even more questions than answers.

Who is “A”? Are there ...