Credit: Instagram

The more time Caleb (Tyler Blackburn) spends in Ravenswood, the more he gets sucked into the supernatural sinkhole of a town. Will the same thing happen to Pretty Little LiarsHanna (Ashley Benson) when she comes to town? How does she react to the supernatural shenanigans that regularly go down in Ravenswood?

Ravenswood executive producer Oliver Goldstick chatted with TV Line about Hanna’s much-anticipated conversation with Caleb in Season 4, Episode 14 (“Who’s in the Box”) of PLL and her return to Ravenswood in Season 1, Episode 10 of Ravenswood. On the prediction that Hanna might scoff at Caleb’s claims of supernatural goings-on, Oliver said: “Exactly — until maybe she experiences something like that herself.”

Yikes! Does that mean Hanna will be targeted by the Ravenswood Big Bad? She spent a sizable amount of time wandering around the Collins Funeral Home in the Halloween ep, but she never saw anything that would lead her to accept the existence of ghosts. It sounds like this might change come a future appearance.

We can’t imagine anything supernatural happening during Caleb’s appearance in Pretty Little Liars’ winter premiere, but Episode 10 of Ravenswood could be dangerous for her!

What do you think it will take for Hanna to believe Caleb’s stories? Will Hanna be targeted by the Ravenswood ghosts? Sound off in the comments below!

Catch the Pretty Little Liars Season 4 winter premiere, Tuesday, January 7, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.