full size The Real Housewives of Atlanta Season 4 Promo
Credit: Quantrell Colbert/Bravo © NBC Universal, Inc.

There’s no questioning our loyalty to the Real Housewives of Atlanta but after a somewhat sleepy start to Season 4, we found ourselves wondering if maybe RHoA is in need of a Real Housewives of New York-style shake up.

Take a look at our assessment of each of the housewives so far this season, and then vote on which housewife you think should leave the show after Season 4!

Cynthia Bailey:  Let’s be honest, Cynthia is nice to look at but she hasn’t added much to the show since joining last season. Sure, watching her plan her wedding to Peter was interesting — and they clearly have some marital issues that need to be resolved — but as far as we know they’re still married, so it’s clear that storyline isn’t going anywhere.

Kandi Burruss: Refreshingly rational Kandi has long been a fan favorite — and we still love her — but we’re starting to wonder if Kandi is too even-keeled for a show like this. Last season, Kandi feuded with Kim over song royalties, but this season she’s been relatively drama-free. Sure, Kandi doesn’t really like NeNe, but she knows better than to start a fight with Ms. Leakes.

NeNe Leakes:  NeNe still has the same no-nonsense attitude she had when the show began, but she’s alienated so many of cast members (aside from Cynthia) that she practically has no one left to film with. However, since NeNe has been spending so much time in L.A., we wouldn’t be surprised if she left the show on her own to pursue other projects.

Phaedra Parks: We still count on Phaedra for hilarious one-liners and great advice, but without the due date drama of last season, her life seems pretty calm. However, Phae-Phae gets bonus points for her adorable husband, Apollo, and her cute son, Ayden.

Sheree Whitfield: So far, Sheree is the only housewife that’s really given us anything good this season — thanks to Chateau Sheree and the child support drama — but both of those story lines have since vanished from the show, leaving Sheree with little to work with.

Kim Zolciak: After meeting the love of her life and giving birth to her third child shortly after, Kim has stayed very close to her growing family this season (understandably so) and hasn’t filmed much with the other girls. However, the geniuses at Bravo picked up on this and offered Kim her own spin-off, so maybe the network has bigger things in store for the wigged one.

What do you think: Which housewife has overstayed her welcome on the Real Housewives of Atlanta?

Vote in our poll below!