Credit: Bravo

On last night’s The Real Housewives of New York (Season 5, Episode 13: “Pirate Booty Call”), it certainly looked like the Countess got caught in a big lie. With all the ladies (minus Aviva Drescher, until next week) in vacation mode in St. Barts, LuAnn de Lesseps couldn’t help noticing the charms of local Frenchman Tomas, a Johnny Depp lookalike. But did she really hook up with the swashbuckling hottie?

As we pointed out after the episode aired, the Countess doth protest a little too much. She told anyone within hearing distance that she had been out with her “Italian friends,” but tweeted that Tomas had driven her home. She gave off a completely innocent facade, until she was overheard by Bravo cameras, telling her friend on the phone that nobody could find out Tomas had come home with her. Oopsies!

Heather Thomson and Carole Radziwill both claimed, several times, that they had heard LuAnn and Tomas talking together in the vacation home very late at night. Neither of them seemed to believe that LuAnn had brought a big group of Italians home.

So who do you believe? In the reaction buttons below, tell us if you believe LuAnn’s story or not.

The Real Housewives of New York airs Mondays at 9 p.m. ET/PT on Bravo.  

Get all the latest RHONY news! Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @RHONYWetpaint.