Sonja Morgan and Carole Radziwill went on a girls-only date on The Real Housewives of New York Season 5, Episode 16: “What Happens in St. Barts Doesn’t Stay in St. Barts”, and they seemed to get along perfectly well. But in Sonja’s blog after the show aired (September 17), Sonja called Carole a “hypocrite” and “judgmental.” What went wrong?

Sonja raises the point that, while on vacation in St. Barts, Carole wasn’t the epitome of a party girl. So it might have been confusing to see Carole getting “bombed” at a gay bar with BFF Heather Thomson.

“The first thing Carole does when she gets back to the city … is state that her plan is to get inebriated,” writes Sonja. “[She] enacts plan, and stumbles out into the public. Nothing wrong with that except would have been great to share a little bit of that with us in St. Barts.”

Uh oh! Sonja went on to say that Carole “is acting too judgmental or a bohemian hippie that lives downtown dating a rockstar who lives in LA, tours most the year, and is in a relationship where they each sleep with other people.”

Do you agree with Sonja that Carole was judging Sonja’s partying a bit too much for someone that clearly likes to enjoy a cocktail now and then herself? Or is Sonja being too sensitive? Somehow, Sonja’s comment about Carole being in an open relationship with a “rockstar” sounds like a passive-aggressive way of throwing major shade...

Tell us what you think!

The Real Housewives of New York airs Mondays at 9 p.m. ET/PT on Bravo.  

Source: Sonja’s BravoTV blog

Get all the latest Housewives news! Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @RHONYWetpaint.