After spending most of Revenge Season 1 rooting for childhood sweethearts Jack Porter and Emily Thorne to finally be together, we have come to a shocking realization in 2013, and are now we’re all for Amanda Clarke to be with her baby daddy and faux-love.

No, she didn’t hit us over the head with a shovel or anything, but it just really seems like they’d be happier together. Emily clearly needs someone with a bit of danger in his life, and apart from getting himself into lots of trouble on accident, Jack Porter has nothing to offer in that department.

Not that he isn’t a babe (well, minus the hair). It’s just that Amanda wants to lead a simple, white-picket-fence-stripper-heels-next-to-the-baby-crib kind of lifestyle, while Ems is all about vengeance and poets named Daniel Grayson.

So could Jack and Amanda really be in love now? They certainly seem to be insync now that they’re wedding planning and he’s making her polluted sea glass necklaces!

But what do you think? Are they really in love? Weigh in below!