Engagements are almost as common as deaths (well maybe not) in the Hamptons, and one couple just put a ring on it for a second time. That’s right, Revenge’s Emily Thorne and Daniel Grayson are taking another shot at love (without Tila Tequila).

In Season 1, Danny proposed on the deck of a yacht as an orchestra played and the rain poured and a supposedly smitten Emily quickly said yes. Sadly their engagement ended when Emily kissed Jack Porter in a fit of emotion over Sammy the Dog’s dead labrador body (ew, what?!).

Now Daniel’s once again ready to make a commitment to Ms. Thorne, and in Episode 19, “Identity,” he proposed again. Well, sort of. He handed Emily her old ring (gasp!) and told her that if she was wearing it when he saw her next then they’d be together and engaged. Umm, what?

You’re dating the Hamptons’ most eligible bachelor and he re-gifts your engagement ring and fails to really ask for your hand in marriage? Time to upgrade, Ems (by which we mean marry Nolan and make beautiful Nemily babies).

In the end, Emily asked Aiden Mathis if he was OK with her marrying Daniel, and he approved as long as her end game was moving with him to Japan to make little revengey babies. Basically, Emily has a lot of babies to make.

Do you think Emily and Daniel will actually get married this time? Weigh in below!