There’s a devious duo a brewin’ in the Hamptons, y’all. In Revenge Season 2, Episode 18, “Masquerade,” the newly empowered Jack Porter reached out to the fallen Ashley Davenport, asking if she would help him in his quest for Grayson domination.

After Conrad Grayson browbeat his former mistress and current campaign assistant, he left her loyalty up for grabs. Captain Jack leapt at the opportunity to pick up this fashion-forward friend for Team Labrador.

But Ash is known for going wherever the wind (and opportunities) take her. She’s been tied to the Graysons for so long that it might be hard to break that habit. Plus, a family with means and connections offers Ashley a better opportunity than a plaid-wearing barkeep.

Now that she knows what Jack’s up to, she could turn on him and start giving the Graysons inside info (as a double agent).

Lately, Ashley’s conscience has come into play in a big way. She feels guilty about the death of Amanda Clarke and her potential involvement, but is this guilt strong enough for her to remain loyal to Jack?

That remains to be seen. But in the meantime, tell us your theories below!