It’s been weeks since Revenge Season 2, Episode 18, “Masquerade,” aired, but we’re still drooling over Emily Thorne’s breathtaking gown that she wore to the Graysons’ Halloween ball.

We’ve already learned that the dress was a BCBG gown that costs $468, and she wasn’t the first to wear it! Twilight star Tinsel Korey, who played a female werewolf, wore the gown to the Los Angeles premiere of the final film in November 2012.

Emily’s dress was tailored to be more fitted at the bottom while Tinsel’s flowed out from her body. Both ladies opted to wear their hair up with minimal jewelry.

The two actresses showed off ample cleavage in the low-cut halter dress.

So who rocked the dress best: The Revenge-fighting girl next door or the member of the werewolf tribe who betrayed her family to protect Bella Swan and her baby?

Tell us below!