It seems ABC costume designers are shopping out of the same closet these days. In Episode 10 of the country music-fueled drama, Nashville, the villainous Juliette Barnes takes the stage in a glittery red sequin dress. As always, we were dazzled by her look, and a bit concerned that she wasn’t wearing underwear.

A few months later, Victoria Grayson hosted a Halloween masquerade ball in Revenge Season 2, Episode 18, “Masquerade,” wearing a gorgeous floor-length gown covered in black sequins and a snaking pattern.

But wait! Could the queen of the Hamptons actually be wearing the same dress (if not a different color and cut) as a semi-trashy twentysomething starlet? GASP.

That’s right, Victoria and Juliette are both wearing a gorgeous Mandalay dress, which costs about $2k. Both ladies (and their stylists) definitely fine tuned the outfit to match their respective personalities.

Victoria’s long black gown was perfect for the occasion, especially when paired with elbow-length black gloves and a black mask. Juliette’s performance attire was extra short and tight, but was one of her classier looks to date.

Who do you think wore the dress best, Victoria or Juliette? Tell us below!