The couple started dating after playing an on-screen couple in the Hamptons. But they're notorious for keeping their relationship private.
Previously, Emily has dated Joseph Morgan, who plays bad-boy Klaus, an original vampire with demonic designs, on The Vampire Diaries. Emily met the Welsh actor on the set of the 2010 miniseries Ben Hur.
Before Joseph, Emily dated her Everwood co-star Chris Pratt — her on-screen brother (creepy) — from 2004 to 2006. Married to actress Anna Faris since 2009, Chris now creates endless hilarity as bumbling Andy Dwyer on Parks and Recreation.