Credit: Colleen Hayes/ABC Television Group © 2011 Disney Photo: The Guests on the Beach in Season 1, Episode 15: “Chaos”

Is it just us, or was Tyler Barrol beginning to feel like a bad rash? Just when you think he's gone for good, he pops in to steal your Infinity Box, crash your engagement party, and frame you for murder. Good riddance, we say!

But who's responsible for pulling the trigger and sending young Tyler to his untimely demise before his plan is carried out?

Unfortunately, the jury's still out. While Daniel's the obvious suspect thanks to the bloodstains on his jacket, we just don't believe the good-hearted Grayson is our smooth criminal.

That leaves Amanda, who Jack finds crouched over Tyler's lifeless body, but does the blood on her hands belong to her deceased kidnapper? We're not convinced.

Last, but certainly not least, is Mr. Satoshi, Emily's enigmatic sensei. Just before the gunfight goes down, he gives Emily a giant present wrapped in a big red bow, tells her to bury her father's secrets, and promises her questions will be answered by the time she returns.

That sure sounds like code-speak to us! Could Em and sensei have orchestrated the entire ordeal to frame Daniel for a crime he didn't commit? That's one way to get out of a trip to Paris!

Or perhaps it's just a little game of tit for tat … how you like them apples, Vicky G?

Wanna share theories with fellow Revenge fans? Join the discussion on our Revenge Facebook page!
Follow @RevengeWetpaint on Twitter

More About Revenge
Revenge Spoilers
Revenge Photos
Revenge Episodes
Revenge Music
Revenge Relationships