Credit: ABC Photo: Tyler and Nolan Chat Poolside in Revenge Season 1, Episode 10: "Loyalty"

When Nolan (Gabriel Mann) and Tyler (Ashton Holmes) got together on Revenge, it seemed like they were both in it for superficial and nefarious reasons. We didn’t expect either of them to take the relationship too seriously, so when we saw Nolan’s crushed face after Tyler called him pathetic and lonely, we definitely felt for our land-locked boat captain.
But some fans are spitting mad that Nolan was taken in by the shyster — even going so far to say that Revenge ruined its best character with that scene. Do you think Nolan falling for Tyler humanized him or made him look like an irredeemable chump?