Credit: Colleen Hayes/ABC Television Group © 2011 Disney Photo: Daniel, Emily, Ashley, and Tyler Have Dinner on Revenge Season 1, Episode 6: "Intrigue"

Remember when a shape that looked like Daniel’s (Joshua Bowman) perfect body was marred with bullets during Revenge Season 1, Episode 1? Don’t worry, we’re still crying oceans of tears, too.

There’s still no confirmation that Daniel was actually shot, but we can safely assume it’s a possibility. Especially since Victoria (Madeleine Stowe) howled “get away from my son!” when she saw the body. Now the time has come to put on our jauntiest detective fedoras and get deep into the nitty gritty: If Daniel really is dead, who killed him – and why?

Emily (Emily VanCamp), Nolan (Gabriel Mann), Victoria and Conrad (Henry Czerny) were all at the engagement party when Daniel’s body was discovered, and Declan (Connor Paolo) and Charlotte Grayson (Christa Allen) were busy making sweet love on the beach, which leaves Jack (Nick Wechsler) and Tyler sans alibi.

Jack definitely has a motive for killing Daniel (she’s tall, likes swordfish, and speaks Japanese), but he’s always seemed like the “war what is it good for” type. Tyler also has a motive – after all, Daniel is his direct competition to accessing the Grayson empire. Oh, and he’s also a sociopath.

So, which of these bad boys might be a murderer?

Time to put it to a vote!