Credit: Pascal Le Segretain/Staff, Frederick M. Brown/Stringer Photo: Katie Holmes & Kenny Ortega

All season long we've been struggling with the new celebrity guest judge format on So You Think You Can Dance, but last week our faith was renewed when Christina Applegate joined the panel.

She took the no. 1 spot on Wetpaint Entertainment's guest judge ranking, above Neil Patrick Harris, Lady Gaga, and of course, Carmen Electra, who came in dead last.

After this week, however, we may have a tie on our hands for last place …

Yes, Katie Holmes grew up taking tap lessons (what child in America didn't?), and she's a founding member of the Dizzy Feet Foundation, but does that make her qualified to judge dance from a technical perspective? If last night was any indication, the answer is no.

Thank goodness for director Kenny Ortega, who offered the contestants legitimate feedback (even if plugging the Dirty Dancing reboot seemed to be his top priority). The best thing Mrs. Tom Cruise could dredge up was "I liked it" and "You look great” or comments about the contestants’ shoes. Suri could have done a better job!

Do you agree with us? Was Katie Holmes the worst celebrity guest judge of the season? Take the poll below and then join the discussion on Facebook!