Credit: Twitter

It's our favorite time of the day, watermelon bingers. Yep, It's Gary Time! Teen Mom's Gary Shirley is the most popular baby daddy in MTV land, but there's another Gary trying to steal his studly throne. Who is it, you ask? It’s none other than Jenelle Evans' ex-fiancé, Gary Head!

When Mr. Head first swaggered into Teen Mom land, we weren't sure our bodies were ready for more than one Gary (mo' Garys, mo' problems), but how wrong we were. Turns out two Garys are better than one, though the fact these bros share the same name can be all kinds of confusing — even for MTV!
"Received a call today from @MTV they were talking to me thinking I was gary head lol," Gary Shirley tweeted on March 11. "I'm kinda offended."

It's a common mistake to make, but why would MTV be contacting Gary Head? Boyfriend isn't even dating Jenelle anymore (the two split up while Jenelle sought treatment at a rehab facility in Florida) and spends his days pining for his on-again/off-again girlfriend, Jade Dolph.

"LOL Thats funny," Gary Head responded. "I have no clue why they are trying to contact me."

Um, someone at MTV is clearly a huge fan of people named Gary and just wanted to partake in a bonding session. We've all been there, right guys?

Who is your favorite Gary: Teen Mom 2’s Gary Head or Teen Mom’s Gary Shirley? Sound off below!