Credit: ABC

On the Bachelor Season 18 “Women Tell All” special on March 3, the ladies of Juan Pablo Galavis’s harem put on quite the show. While most WTAs are reserved for weave-pulling, hoop earring-snatching, and intrafemale fighting, this one was all about the love among castmates. Unless, of course, your name was Juan Pablo.

When Andi Dorfman was called up into the hot seat, she did a great job of repeating the talking points we got to know during her exit from the Fantasy Suites. She said that there’s a difference between honesty and being a d-bag (check), reiterated that it’s not rad to talk about hooking up with other girls (double check), and then threw us all for a loop when she said that she faked being asleep to get away from Juan Pablo and his repeated “Ess okay.” Yikes.

Sharleen Joynt, meanwhile, took a different route than we expected. While we always knew that she was a classy broad, she upped her game even more when she deviated from the name calling to give her ex some props. It would’ve been easy to join in the witch hunt, but instead she told fans that Juan Pablo seemed genuinely “curious” about her, and even detailed the conversations the cameras failed to catch. In all, she presented herself exactly as someone with mundo should. And we had to wonder if maybe she’d be the best choice to be the next Bachelorette.

Andi is rumored to take the reins on Season 10 of the ABC show when it kicks off in late May, but would you rather watch her find love or take a gander at Sharleen’s journey? Weigh in below with your feels, and we’ll be sure to pass them on!