Season 18 Bachelor Juan Pablo Galavis had one job on his last dates with the final two women: to show Nikki Ferrell and Clare Crawley what a life with him would be like. And it seems that the 32-year-old single dad did just that. On his final day with Clare Crawley, 32, he took the beautiful hairstylist on a romantic helicopter ride in St. Lucia, but it turned ugly, according to an insider.

Wetpaint Entertainment spoke with a source close to the show who gave us the disturbing details on what happened. In an ITM (in the moment interview) after her helicopter ride, Clare says that in their few camera-free minutes on the chopper, Juan Pablo insulted her terribly. “Juan Pablo leaned over and whispered something to me. He chose to tell me something that no woman wants to hear,” Clare tells the camera. “I almost… I don’t have words for it, how I feel right now.”

So, what was it that went down when it was just the two of them alone with the pilot? “Clare asked Juan Pablo, ‘Just tell me you love me,’” knowing that the Bachelor may be hesitant to declare such a thing on camera, the insider says. “And he said, ‘I really loved f—ing you.’”

Sorry, what was that? There’s no English-to-Spanish dictionary that could make that sound better. And while we weren’t on the helicopter with her, we wish we could’ve been in the moment to help Clare through such a shocking statement. (Or help her push him out…) Who says that? Reportedly, Juan Pablo. That’s who.

Are you shocked at what Juan Pablo said to Clare when they were alone? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

Julia Wayne is an Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!