Throughout much of the Bachelor Season 18 Finale, Clare Crawley seemed hopelessly in love with Juan Pablo Galavis. She was swept up in the romance. Even when his family warned that Juan Pablo definitely had his faults, Clare seemed not to hear it. Until the moment he whispered something in her ear. And then all her romantic illusion came crashing down.

Clare was too offended by Juan Pablo’s remark to utter it on TV, but Wetpaint Entertainment  has learned exclusively exactly what was said. Clearly upset and hurt by being so blatantly objectified, Clare wondered if Juan Pablo actually had any true feelings for her at all.

She confronted him, and the resulting conversation got members of Bachelor nation tweeting up a storm! Most — but not all — seemed to be Team Clare, until the blonde beauty let herself be talked out of all her doubts, and ended the night saying she felt convinced that all her fears were for naught.

But then! In a startling moment (for everyone who didn’t read the spoilers), he eliminated her. Her epic speech got people back on #TeamClare, and we imagine they’re there to stay. Check out what everyone had to say.


Team Clare

NOT Team Clare

He Talked Her Out of It?

After the Elimination