The Bachelor 2014 came down to a battle between Nikki Ferrell and Clare Crawley for Juan Pablo Galavis’s heart, and though Nikki won that one, it’s not over yet. We asked Viggle LIVE! users who tuned in for the epic Season 18 finale which girl won another battle: best dressed. We thought it’d be a tight race. but it wasn’t! And Nikki won the award once again.

Dressed in a cowl-neck navy blue floor (or beach, as it was in St. Lucia) length gown, 65 percent of Viggle users thought she picked the perfect gown to get engaged in wear when she received Juan Pab’s final rose. The long slit showed off her enviable stems, and we totally give this one to her.

Want to play along? Download the FREE Viggle App now!

Clare Crawley's one-shouldered aqua gown thrilled the other 35 percent of Viggle app voters, who thought her incredible dress was a great choice for the 32-year-old beauty. Perhaps it was its similarity to Vienna Girardi’s Season 14 finale dress, but we definitely get why so many people would love to wear it — even while getting rejected.

Want to play along with your favorite shows? It’s easy! All you have to do is download Viggle, check in, and start racking up points to redeem for the best rewards. No drama, no tears, no false hopes of an engagement that’s never going to come. Maybe the Bachelor girls should try it...

Julia Wayne is an Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!