Credit: Valerie Macon/Getty Images

Before she headed off into the sunset with her floppy-haired prince Ben Flajnik, Bachelor 16 winner Courtney Robertson had quite a star-studded dating life. The gorgeous model has copped to dating such big screen stars as Jesse Metcalfe and Adrien Grenier, and now she’s spilling all the deets in her juicy tell-all, I Didn’t Come Here to Make Friends. But Court’s ex that we’re most interested in? An industry bigwig who is now hitched to one of our fave leading ladies.

Courtney’s more big-name exes are getting all of the attention these days — who knew Vinny Chase was such a stud, eh? — but we had a feeling that not as many people were aware of the TV vixen’s other Hollywood romance. Thus, we asked Viggle LIVE! users if they could figure out which famous blond actress is now married to Court’s ex.

We couldn’t get this one past nearly half of the users; a majority 49 percent of the vote correctly opted for the legally blonde Reese Witherspoon, whose hubby is talent agent Jim Toth. Meanwhile, 37 percent believed that Drew Barrymore’s art consultant spouse Will Kopelman had a history with Courtney. And only 14 percent of users went with Sarah Michelle Gellar — which, FYI to them, Freddie Prinze, Jr. has been married to the former vampire slayer for 12 years, so that’s impossible.

So yes, our favorite Bachelor “villain” has a romantic past with Reese’s hunky baby daddy, Jim. As the story goes, Courtney allegedly wasn’t looking for commitment, while a then-38 year old Jim was ready for the long haul. Plus, the two dated not long before Jim hooked up with Reese, so thank goodness that didn’t work out!

Are you surprised by Courtney’s connection to Reese? Sound off in the comments! And don’t forget to play along next Monday using your Viggle app. Get the FREE download below and start racking up those rewards!