Credit: ABC via WENN/Instagram/Twitter

Tonight on The Bachelorette 2012 finale, 27-year-old Utah entrepreneur Jef Holm asked Emily Maynard to be his wife — and she said yes!

So while everything seems perfect for Team Jem, it’s not all happiness and rainbows for everyone in Curacao. Arie Luyendyk, Jr., the charming 30-year-old race car driver from Arizona, went home with a broken heart.

Naturally, plenty of people have been speculating that Arie could be the next Bachelor. The only problem is, we already have two very strong candidates in the running for the gig.

Back in early June, spoiler king Reality Steve reported that Season 6 Bachelorette winner (and Ali Fedotowsky's ex) Roberto Martinez, 29, was "1000% Signed, Sealed, Delivered" the next Bachelor. Host Chris Harrison later said that such reports were “overblown,”but we know plenty of women (ie: us!) who would love to see Roberto get another shot at love.

However, we just can’t stop thinking about Sean Lowe, either. Plenty of fans were up in arms to see Emily eliminated the hunky 29-year-old Texan, and reports that he is in line for the gig, as well, have been met with much excitement.

That said, we don’t get to have three Bachelors in one season, so two of these guys will (unfortunately?) be left to search for love outside of the glare of the reality TV spotlight. If it was up to you, which of these three contenders would you like to see headliningThe Bachelor Season 17 this winter?

Need your daily dose of The Bachelorette? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter. After all, you’d get our final rose.