Sean Lowe has a tough choice to make tonight on The Bachelor 2013 finale. Lindsay Yenter or Catherine Giudici? Well, if Sean were to ask some of the ladies he sent home, Lesley Murphy says the answer is clear: Sean should pick Catherine.

We’re not surprised that Lesley chose Catherine. The two ladies had such a close connection during their time on The Bachelor that they’re basically besties now. Catherine even cried when Lesley was sent home and wondered what she was still doing there.

What do you think — does Lesley know what’s best for Sean, or is she letting her feelings for Catherine color her judgment?