Credit: ABC

Fact: When you show up on the very first night of The Bachelor wearing a wedding dress, people are bound to take notice. And not only did 2013 contestant Lindsay Yenter show up in a wedding dress, but she also asked Sean Lowe to dance with her! (Sidenote: She may have consumed a fair amount of alcohol before the now-famous dance, as well.)

Bachelor Nation loves to tweet as they watch the latest Bachelor episodes, and plenty of noted alums took note of Lindsay’s first-impression garb. What did fan favorites like Arie Luyendyk, Jr. and J.P Rosenbaum think of her big Bachelor debut?

As soon as Lindsay made her comment about having balls, Season 7 Bachelorette winner JP Rosenbaum tweeted, “Goofy side = wacko side = prob does have balls #stayaway #Bachelor”

Bachelorette Season 8 runner-up Arie tweeted, “Is Lindsay drunk ALREADY? #DrunkBrideDoesntGetTheGroom#Bachelor”

Then, Chris Bukowski tweeted, “One more drink for Lindsay please...#Bachelor”

Bachelor Pad 3 winner/villain Nick Peterson chimed in, “Wedding dress when meeting a guy for the first time: bad idea.”

Yet the one with the most to say was winner Bachelor Pad 2 winner Holly Durst tweeted, “Wedding Dress Girl... First of all... you have already said "Balls" twice during this episode. Second...the wedding dress was probably not the best idea and third... you drank too much! #balls”

Just because Lindsay didn’t make the best first impression, that doesn’t necessarily mean she’s out of the race quite yet. Click here to find out whether or not she makes it into Sean’s final four!