Bachelor Ben Flajnik put a ring on Courtney Robertson at the end of The Bachelor 16, and our hearts melted — but not before we got a look at that custom-designed Neil Lane ring that Ben used to pop the question. Holy sparkles, we swooned.

Fast forward a few months to Liam Hemsworth and Miley Cyrus’ engagement announcement and ring details . . .

Hold up, double take — that looks a lot like Courtney’s ring!  But how do the two Neil Lane diamond rings compare to one another? We’re glad you asked.


Courtney’s Ring (On the Right):
Stone: 3+ carat diamond solitaire, accented by 96 round cut diamonds.
Metal: Platinum
Cost: $50, 000

Miley’s Ring (On the Left): 
Stone: 3.5 carat 19th century hand-cut diamond solitaire, with round cut accent diamonds.
Metal: 18K gold
Cost: $250,000 

Final Winner: 
We can’t choose — after all, true love is the eye of the beholder! 

But whose ring do you prefer — Courtney’s platinum sparkler or Miley’s antique solitaire? Let us know!

Need your daily dose of The Bachelor? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter. After all, you’d get our final rose.