Credit: ABC video still

Tonight is Andi Dorfman’s night with her three remaining fellas in the band of brosefs on The Bachelorette — aka the time when the 27-year-old takes her boys to the Fantasy Suites. And every season at this point, the question starts to surface: Which Bachelor or Bachelorette has slept with the most people on their season?


There have been Bachelorettes, like Season 8’s Emily Maynard, who skipped the “fantasy” part of the suite, either not offering the key, or keeping it PG (at least on screen). Sean Lowe famously refused the sex part of the relationships until he married his Season 17 winner, Catherine Giudici. However, his predecessor, Ben Flajnik, did no such thing, as Season 16 winner Courtney Robertson revealed in her tell-all book.

We don’t know exactly what Andi will do, but Reality Steve has hinted that she definitely makes the most of her time. Will she have a Juan Pablo Galavis-style problem, where one of the guys, like Andi, pulls out (sorry, we had to!) post-coitally? Who knows, but let’s talk history.

Former Bachelorette Ali Fedotowsky has spilled in the past as to who the anti-Sean Lowe is. Ladies, meet Season 4 Bachelor Bob Guiney. “Mike Fleiss, the creator of the show, said Bob Guiney had sex with like 16 girls or something on the show!” Ali revealed last year around this time to Chicago blog A Drink With, adding, “I heard he went in the bathroom during dates to have sex with the girls.”

Dayum! For his part, Mike Fleiss confirms "there is sex" during filming for The Bachelor. In an interview for ABC’s Inside The Bachelor special, the show creator went so far as to give an average number of lays per Bachelor. "I think the average is that the guy will end up having sex with about three women during the course of the show." Hmm, you mean because of the Fantasy Suites and the three girls who make it to bed with them?

Well, if Ali’s correct, then Bob Guiney is far from your average man — and that apparently also applies to his bedding abilities. Asked which Bachelor has the most notches on their bed post, Mike gleefully (and creepily) knew the answer. "That's my man Bob Guiney!"

But you can dial down the gagging a little bit, since Ali is apparently wrong about one thing, if Mike Fleiss’s Bachelor Mansion sex flowchart is correct. Bob didn’t sleep with 16 women — more like five. Or, as Mike put it, "I think it was five and half." Hey Mike, one more question: What about the Bachelorettes?

What do you think about that answer? Which Bachelorette do you think has slept with the most guys? Sound off below!

Sources: A Drink With, ABC