Lindsay Yenter: First Runner-Up
Lindsay Yenter lost out to Catherine in the Thailand finale, making us fall in love with her when she hopped off her high heels and barefooted it away from Sean. But though we were a little broken hearted for her, it wasn't no thang for Linds. The army brat moved to San Diego, met boyfriend Karl, and is living happily ever after!
Fun fact: Lindsay met her boyfriend because he's her best friend's boyfriend's brother!