Bachelor 16 After the Final Rose Rumor Roundup: What’s True, What’s False? — Spoiler Alert!

*WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD!!!!*

Not to say “We told you so,” but… we did call it weeks ago! Wetpaint Entertainment was the first to report that Ben Flajnik did, indeed, propose to Courtney Robertson with a stunning cushion-cut, Neil Lane sparkler during the Bachelor Season 16 finale, which filmed this past November.

This Monday, March 12, the two will make their first public appearance together on the After the Final Rose special, which will air directly after the finale.

In recent days, tons of media outlets have trumped what they claim are exclusive details from the ATFR taping. But, according to our Bachelor sources — who, for the record, have not been wrong yet — not all of them are true.

Read on to see what you can believe — and what you can dismiss as total BS.