3. Jake Pavelka, The Bachelorette Season 5, The Bachelor Season 14, and Bachelor Pad Season 2
Jake Pavelka didn’t leave The Bachelorette Season 5 or The Bachelor Season 14 with a ton of fans, and doing Bachelor Pad Season 2 only strengthened America’s perception of him as someone who loves the spotlight more than anything else. Contestants on BP weren't hiding their desire to see him leave, thanks to his ex, Vienna Girardi, and her new boyfriend, Kasey Kahl, who planted major seeds of dissent in the house before Jake arrived. The strange thing was: their plan backfired and actually made them look worse, while Jake looked better than he ever had before.