Ali Fedotowsky & Roberto Martinez
The 18-month engagement that followed Bachelorette Ali Fedotowsky and her chosen man Roberto “Hottie Dimples” Martinez seemed blissfull from the outside, but, according to Ali, there were problems from the beginning. Ultimately their break-up came down to fundamental differences in personality and life goals — Ali being outspoken and social, while introverted Roberto shunned the limelight. While they remain friends, their split sent a shock-wave of sadfaces across all of Bachelor Nation. The rumor of Roberto’s upcoming stint as Bachelor has helped us cope with the heartache.