2. Jason dumps Melissa for Molly
Not only was this one of the biggest moments ever to happen on The Bachelor, it marked the debut of Bachelor spoilers. Through Jason Mesnick’s season, blogger Reality Steve teased some wild information he had about the finale. He ultimately revealed that sweet single dad Jason had proposed to Melissa Rycroft in the finale, then had a change of heart. Instead of just dumping her quietly off camera, The Powers That Be made both Jason and Melissa sit down for an official televised dumping during the “After the Final Rose” special, during which Melissa called Jason a bastard. During the same special, Molly Malaney came out so Jason could tell her he still had feelings for her and wanted to take her out. It was painfully awkward and put Jason in the hot seat as The Most Hated Bachelor Ever, stealing the crown from Brad Womack. Now Jason and Molly are happily married — and so is Melissa — but nothing can take away the cringe-inducing shock of that switcheroo.