Who knew Kirsten Dunst and Jimmy Fallon were such devoted Bachelor fans? They recently gushed about their love on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon. Kirsten usually prefers The Bachelor, but Jimmy really loved Ali Fedotowsky's season of The Bachelorette (even if he couldn't pronounce her name). They both love her rejected suitor Kasey Kahl — "That's my dude," Jimmy said as Kirsten called him one of her favorite contestants ever. They both started singing a classic Season 6 Kasey song — and Kirsten seemed to have it memorized. She’s good! "And he's always talking about protecting and guarding her heart," Kirsten said, laughing. "He got a tattoo saying I will protect and guard you! That guy's out of his mind," Jimmy said. "He's so creepy," Kirsten laughed, then added, "Sorry, Kasey. We love you! We love you!"