Credit: Craig Sjodin/ABC Television Group © 2012 Disney

In case you’re having trouble distinguishing the Bachelorette Season 9 beefcakes from one another, James Case is the contestant with the SUPER white teeth, olive skin, and dark hair. In his cutest moment thus far, he told Desiree Hartsock in Episode 3 that he really likes her, but that with an ailing father back home, he only wants to stick around if she likes him too. Man, if only we could be so forthcoming. Especially considering that Des’ reply was a group date rose!

So, how many more roses are in James’ (aka “Aladdin”) future? Well, during Episode 4 he gets a 1-on-1 date, hanging in Atlantic City with Des and meeting up with a family devastated by Hurricane Sandy. He must’ve continued to show his sensitive side, because he gets a rose on his date. But is it the last one?

Nope. In fact, James ventures to Europe with Des and the dudes, hitting Munich, Germany for a snowy good time, and then venturing on to Barcelona. Sadly, though, Spain is his last stop. And though we imagine there are worse places to be eliminated (um, like on a bench outside a mansion when your ex shows up), we’ll be sad to see him go. So far, he hasn’t gotten a ton of screen time, but word is that his elimination is not without merit.

What happens exactly? According to Reality Steve, James gets in a major fight with another contestant — Kasey Stewart — and Des boots him out (what’s Spanish for “get out of my coven”?). Will you be sad to see James go? Weigh in.

Source: Reality Steve