Okay, pretty much every Bachelorette fan knows about J.P. Rosenbaum, the adorably charming NYC native who stole Ashley Hebert’s heart during Season 7 — and later married her in a romantic December 2012 ceremony. But the sarcastic and silly Mr. Rosenbaum is not the only J.P. in Bachelor Nation whom we just can’t stop swooning over.

Credit: Lou Rocco/ABC Television Group © 2013 Disney

What about Juan Pablo Galavis? Of all the men competing for Desiree Hartsock’s heart on The Bachelorette 2013, the Venezuela-raised Juan Pablo quickly emerged as a fan favorite. That smile. That accent. Those abs. Um, swoon.

Sadly, Desiree sent our beloved J.P. Galavis packing in Season 9 Episode 6. While we don’t agree with her decision at all, there is one upside: Juan Pablo is single... and not engaged to Des. In our minds, at least, we’re pretty sure we still have a chance.

Credit: Instagram

Last but not least is Justin Pasutto, the boyfriend of Season 5 Bachelorette Jillian Harris. Sure, he may not actually have appeared on one of the Bachelor franchise shows, but he’s still an honorary member of Bachelor Nation. Oh, and he’s super hot.

Justin is a professional snowboarder / wakeboarder from Canada. He and Jilly aren’t engaged, but she recently told Wetpaint Entertainment “I know he’s the one! Yeah, he’s the one, absolutely.”

There you have it. Three J.P.s. Each of them ridiculously attractive in their own ways. So now it’s time for you to make the final call: It’s Rosenbaum vs. Juan Pablo vs. Justin — Which J.P. is the hottest of them all?