Credit: ABC

Recycling is totally en vogue, especially since Bachelorettes are always cast-offs from their season of The Bachelor. Broken hearts mean big numbers, but one gal called it quits on her Bachelor season, only to be cast straight away as the next Bachelorette. We asked Viggle users if they knew who that lovely lady is, and more than a third knew it was Ali Fedotowsky!

Viggle LIVE! app users jumped on our quiz like it was a wine cooler in Bachelor Mansion, and 39 percent of respondents knew that Ali was the girl we’re talking about. While on Jake Pavelka’s Season 14, she peaced out after Hometowns so she wouldn’t lose her job at Facebook. Later, she called him to try and get back on the show, but was brutally rebuffed. She got her chance at redemption on Season 6 of The Bachelorette.

Download the Viggle app now! Check it out:

Vigglers had a tough time with the question, with 34 percent of ringers-in sure that Season 4 Bachelorette DeAnna Pappas also said auf Wiedersehen from Season 11 of The Bachelor. In reality, she was one of Brad Womack’s ditched final two on his first go at being the Bachelor.

Another 27 percent of users thought Jillian Harris had walked away. As if! She made it all the way to Jason Mesnick’s final three before being dumped for Melissa Rycroft… er, we mean Molly Malaney (now Mesnick). Jilly was a fast favorite and kicked butt as the Bachelorette for Season 5.  

Would you have known that Ali is so far the only Bachelor contestant who walked away on her own two feet only to be cast in the next season? Duh, cuz you’re a faithful Wetpaint Entertainment reader. Next time, let your prowess show and earn points just for showing off your enviable Bachelor Nation knowledge. All you have to do is download the Viggle app, check into the show (like, tonight, for example) and start racking up points. Follow in Ali’s footsteps and make the right choice…


Julia Wayne is an Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!