Credit: Rick Rowell/ABC Television Group © 2014 Disney Photo: Brett Melnick and Andi Dorfman in the Bachelorette Season 10 Premiere

We barely know how to walk into a first date without making fools of ourselves, so we have to hand it to the 25 guys who arrived in suits to rock Andi Dorfman’s world on The Bachelorette’s May 19 Season 10 premiere. While some guys managed to pull off a suavity we can’t even touch, others did the “aww shucks” awkward thing with aplomb. But there were two guys who might want a first impression do-over, winning them the dubious honor of competing for this week's Bachelorette Bleachable Moment presented by Clorox.

The two guys battling it out were 26-year-old Dylan Petitt and mulleted Brett Melnick. Their entrances weren’t necessarily the most cringe-worthy (never forget Emil Schaffroth’s name pronunciation lesson), but we bet they’d like their first steps back…

Movie star-hot Dylan had it on lock — until he stood two feet away from Andi and admitted to losing all his words. While 45 percent of Viggle LIVE! voters thought it was hard to watch Dylan choke, 55 percent found Brett’s arrival to be the bigger Bleachable Moment.

Download the Viggle app and check in with Viggle LIVE! during The Bachelorette every Monday at 8 p.m. ET to play along and rack up points for cool prizes!

Hairstylist Brett got the “awkward music” edit when he hopped out of the limo, then reached back in to grab… a lamp. And not a little one, either. The 29-year-old from Warminster, Pennsylvania, handed Andi a giant lamp, telling her that his mom said never to greet a date empty handed. Uh, OK pal. Guess they were out of chocolates at the store?

Oh, and the best part? He stole it from the hotel. Yikes! OK, so we actually thought it was pretty funny, but maybe not the way into Andi’s heart. Still, both guys got roses, so it couldn't have been that bad for 27-year-old Atlantan Andi.

Did you look away when Dylan and Brett flubbed their first impressions? Want to weigh in on whose was more awk? Voting is still open for this week, and you'll have plenty of chances to vote throughout Season 10. Just make sure to check in with Viggle LIVE! for this and other opportunities to play along during our favorite rose-colored show. Plus, you’ll earn points for cool stuff like song downloads to make a perfect soundtrack for your own entrance…


Julia Wayne is an Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!