Monday’s episode of The Bachelorette was full of man fighting, but it was also full of tongue wrestling. Josh Murray scored his first 1-on-1 date with Andi Dorfman aboard a sailboat in Marseilles and Mr. Kiss Happy wasted no time laying anchor on Andi’s shores. (Boat humor!)

Thought the date seemed super romantic enough to push Josh into frontrunner territory (sorry Nick Viall), former Bachelorette Jillian Harris still isn’t on board with Josh captaining Andi’s ship. Despite a deep talk the lovebirds had when they stopped smooching and came up for salty sea air, Jilly writes in her blog that she’s “Still VERY skeptical of his intentions and where there [sic] relationship is going.”

The Jill-bill does admit that she wouldn’t make the man walk the plank for eating crackers in bed, however, writing “He is cute!” And she gushed about their date, calling it a “fairytale” and writing that “The first one-on-one date with Josh was supppperrr cute...their boat ride, picnic and dinner at the palace were soooo picturesque and perfect.” But cute comes with a caveat.

“BUT,” Jillian writes, “I think she’s totally right….there’s clearly some questions that need to be asked and it’s hard to tell if they really click!” Wait, was she watching the same episode we were? From where we were sitting, they did nothing but click.  

What do you think of Jillian’s take on Josh? Hit us up in the comments.

Source: Jillian’s blog