Is it possible to fall in love with two people at once? At the beginning of The Bachelorette, Episode 5, Chris Harrison asked Andi Dorfman if she was falling in love. After trotting out her trademark “stahp,” the Dorf admitted that indeed she was developing feelsies... for more than one guy! Of course we weren’t given their names, but we’re pretty sure they rhyme with Vick Niall and Mosh Jurray.  

Sharleen Joynt, the fashionista who excused herself from Juan Pablo Galavis’s season of The Bachelor, agrees. In her blog, which recaps the show weekly, Shar is torn between which of Andi’s frontrunners has better chemistry with the southern gal: Josh or Nick. The opera singer is one of the few on Tricky Nicky’s side, writing, ”It's obvious Andi likes Nick a LOT. The way she looks at him, and also how she just ‘is’ with him: it's as though she's softer, or more demure. These two are very sweet together and they have serious chemistry.”

But Josh is a heavyweight too, in Shar’s book. “It must be said, the only thing that rivals the way Andi looks at Nick is the way she looks at Josh. These two have serious sparks. This moment [on their 1-on-1] was so intimate I almost felt like I shouldn't be watching.”

This week we’re heading into Hometown Dates, which means if Andi is falling for both guys equally she’s got some tough decisions coming up! So which guy do you think she’s got more chemistry with? Tell us in our Josh vs. Nick chemistry-o-meter poll: