Twitter issued a collective “WTF?!” when Andi Dorfman ditched Chris Soules before letting him into her Fantasy Suite by telling him — get this — she’s just not that into him. Like, who in their right mind is not that into Farmer Fantastic? Andi justified her decision to let Mr. Dimples go early by saying it wouldn’t be fair to make him wait around for another Rose Ceremony to find out that his love is a one-way road. Gah! We get it, but, we so don’t get it.

The internet tended to agree. Bachelor Nation flooded the Twittersphere when C.Soules got his heart handed to him; some people supported Andi for having a grown woman convo, while pretty much everyone else thought the move sucked. The upside? Tweeters agreed that, if he wasn’t already a shoo-in for Bachelor 2015, the dumping made Chris even more likable. There’s no stopping him from getting his plaid on on our small screens now.

What else did Twitter care about? Not much — rightly so, it was kind of the Chris show. Though many tweeters did have opinions on Nick Viall’s fairytale book, with viewers being pretty evenly divided between whether it was sweet or creep. Josh Murray flew under the radar this episode, and most people pretty much decided he’s going to win the whole shebang.

Check out our roundup of the best tweets from the episode, then tell us your thoughts in the comments: