While some ladies get “Will You Marry Me” splashed across a jumbotron and have to answer with half a hotdog and mustard hanging out of their mouths, Andi Dorfman gets a romantic seaside proposal in the Dominican Republic complete with a 3-carat Neil Lane sparkler. Life’s totes fair, right ladies?

Andi's proposal moment is pretty perfect — she looks like a goddess in her Carmen Marc Valvo gown and Josh Murray can’t stop grinning he’s so full of love — which is why we’ve watched it like, a million times already. While his “I’ve never felt this way before” speech felt a bit memorized (we can probably thank the producers for that), it was still heartfelt and heartwarming.

Her admission of feelsies for him started out a bit colder — to the point that it scared him into thinking he wasn’t getting a rose — but ended with an admission of the Dorf being “madly in love” with Josh and wanting to have his babies. Awwww.

And then they sort of fell into baby talk and started playing the whole, “I love you more!” “no, I love you more!” game, which gave us a glimpse into their schmoopy woopy future together. Normally, we’d turn our nose at that kind of excessively verbal PDA, but in their case, it was actually sort of adorable.

Watch the proposal below, then tell us your thoughts on it in the comments:

Source: ABC