Credit: ABC/Marc Edwards

You know how it sort of feels like Andi Dorfman and Josh Murray have known each other for forever? Well, there’s some truth to that sentiment — though don’t go calling the bs police on the ABC producers or anything. These two didn’t officially meet until Josh exited the limo last in The Bachelorette Season 10 premiere, but the former pro baller did admit he’d seen Andi before…


At da club! That’s right. Since these two are both Atlanta natives, it’s no surprise that their paths would have crossed at some point (we always assumed they probably had a friend or two in common). That fact was confirmed when the future Mr. and Mrs. Murray stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live! after the finale last night.

“We were at a club one time and I saw her but I wasn’t allowed to say anything,” Josh revealed. “I’m very shy, so I wasn’t going to go up to her and talk to her. And I wasn’t allowed to at that time either, because I was casting.”

Lest you think there was something fishy going on, though, Andi added she wasn’t the Bachelorette yet, but Josh was already a contender for Season 10 contestant. Interesting… it’s like chicken before the egg stuff going on right here! Plus, the Dorf insists she didn’t see him.

“Because if I saw him, of course, I would never have gone on the show. I would have just started dating him then!” she quipped, as her hubby-to-be blushed. But seriously, you guys, you could have saved the public humiliation and just met that night. Let’s be honest...

Source: Jimmy Kimmel Live!