Ali Fedotowsky is so over Roberto Martinez. Clearly. But we didn’t know she was Frank Neuschaefer over him.

During footage of the Bachelor Reunion/Bachelor Pad 3 casting even in Vegas, which was shown in the first few minutes of Ben Flajnik’s Women Tell All special , Ali faced her Season 7 frontrunner-turned-deserter in a shockingly... not-shocking reunion. It as almost as if Ali was expecting to see the guy who broke her heart after leaving the show to get back with his ex (which, btw, didn’t work out).

We know Frank was hoping to see Ali as he said it to the cameras. Cut to... Ali saying, about Frank, YOU NEVER KNOW! Are we the only ones whose heads are exploding right now? Could Ali really consider dating Frank after all this time? Wasn’t he the one who said that leaving Ali was “the best decision I ever made”?

Or... are they just setting us up for a faux romance on the upcoming Bachelor Pad 3? Ali was on our wish list for the upcoming BP season, but we imagined Roberto as the source of all the ex drama a la Jake-Vienna-Kasey love triangle. But Frank could work, too...

So what’s the real deal? Reality Steve had some inside scoop on that potential pairing, if you don’t mind getting spoiled.

What do you think, Bachelor fans? Could you see these two together again? If only for the cameras of BP 3? Or would Ali be better off staying far, far away...

 

**UPDATE: Apparently we weren't the only ones wondering about Ali and her BP3-slash-relationship status. During the WTA Monday night, Ali tweeted, "Wait, I'm confused. Why does everyone think I am going to be on #Bachelor Pad 3. Just so you guys know...I'm not." Well there you have it.

Need your daily dose of The Bachelorette? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter. After all, you’d get our final rose.