Credit: ABC via WENN

Sean Lowe was faced with zero easy decisions during The Bachelor Season 17, Episode 8: Hometown Dates, in which he went head-to-head with a two-star major general, not to mention Catherine Giudici’s sisters, and — last but not least — Desiree Hartsock’s brother. At the end of the episode, Sean sent Desiree home, and even he didn’t seem convinced he’d made the right decision. “I’ve been praying for clarity this entire time, and every rose ceremony, I seem to get it, and this time I didn’t get it.” Sean then added, “I’m not certain this decision is the best for both you and me.”

You know who’s definitely sure this decision is not best for both Sean and Desiree? Our beloved Bachelor Nation BFFs, who took to the internet in unison to chant mutiny. Here are our favorite Twitter reactions:

Jason Biggs@JasonBiggs
Asshole just let the best girl go home. #TheBachelor #HeWillRegretIt
Ali Fedotowsky@AliFedotowsky
Despite what happened on the hometown dates, I am genuinely shocked about who Sean sent home. #bachelor @eonline
Sarah Newlon@SarahNewlon
Breaking news: Des' brother and Tierra are now engaged.#soulmates #bachelor
Paige Vigil@paigevigil
Legit the hardest #Bachelor breakup I've ever watched!
Ali Fedotowsky@AliFedotowsky
Based on the 3 girls left, it is obvious to me that Sean picks Catherine. Still think the other 2 girls are great @eonline #bachelor
Paige Vigil@paigevigil
@sweettaterblog: Desiree just became the bachelorette with that exit.” I hope so. #thebachelor #Bachelorette
Rachel Truehart@RachTrue_
That goodbye made me tear up