Sarah Herron was Sean Lowe’s first pick for a one-on-one date on The Bachelor Season 17, but no one has forgotten how awkward it was when he pulled her out of a group date, walked her down the hall, dumped her, made her walk back, and then didn’t even carry her bags... So, when she showed her beautiful face on Season 17: “Women Tell All,” there were bound to be a lot of feelings... felt.

As opposed to every other girl representing on the episode, it’s obvious that Sarah is the one truly beloved by everyone who watched her heartbreak at the hand of the splotchy red one. Will Sarah be the next Bachelorette? We’d love that if for nothing more than the joy of seeing her fantastic style week after week. Oh, and cuz she deserves love...

Dana Weiss@Possessionista
The real accomplishment is not that @sarahherron does so much with one arm, but that she NEVER gets it wrong with her dresses#Bachelor

Jennifer Weiner@jenniferweiner
Depressing: Sarah can pack, dress, do hair and makeup better with one hand than I can with two. Or could with three. #bachelornation

Sarah Newlon@SarahNewlon
Watching Sarah is a good reminder that I have real emotions because she breaks my heart everytime I watch her on tv.#TheBachelor #WTA

Mix and Match Mama@MixandMatchMama
@sarahherron you're the only contestant I've tweeted...@SeanLowe09 nephew Smith is in love with you! Youre amazing girl! You have sparkle!

Marissa May@MarissajustMay
Sarah is straight killing it. Preach for us single ladies, girl! #bachelor

Jennifer Weiner@jenniferweiner
All snark aside, I would love it if Sarah met and fell in love with someone great.#nomorefriendzone #bachelornation

Billy Bush@billybush
I love Sarah but the tears are hard to get. At the time you got bumped he was kissing 8 other women. Hold some back girl. #thebachelor

Dana Weiss@Possessionista
"I think I'm funny. And I think I'm smart. And I think I'm great." Maybe we could work on the modesty, Sarah. #Bachelor