First night on Bachelor Pad 3, and things are already getting shady.

Reid Rosenthal tried in vain to save superfan Paige Vigil by campaigning on her behalf and against Erica Rose — and poor Chris Bain didn’t stand a chance once fellow-superfan David Mallet’s plan was revealed to the vets. But did the right people get sent home?

Isn’t it a better strategy to target the threats rather than kill off the weak links?  Who do you think should have gone home? Let us know below!

Want more Bachelor Pad goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!