Credit: Instagram

When we exclusively reported Jef Holm’s new relationship with his 23-year-old Louisiana lady, Katianna Bear, we couldn’t help but think she bore a striking resemblance to another Southern belle in Jef’s life. Emily Maynard and Katianna both have beautiful goldilocks, sweet smiles, and a strong affinity for knee-high boots. Jef definitely has a type!

Now that we have another exclusive report that Jef hooked up with both Emily and Katianna the weekend of Ashley & J.P.’s wedding, we have to ask — which of Jef’s ladies do you think is hotter?

We know this is basically like asking you who’s the cutest of too drop-dead-adorable puppies, but try your best.