Ian McKee, Season 2
We may be the only fans on the planet still obsessed with Ian, but so be it. Meredith Phillips probably knew Ian was trouble when he walked in — and she picked him anyway. Not that Ian was a bad guy, he was just a former NYC investment banker turned “vagabond” who appeared to pop into the show on a lark. He didn’t seem ready for marriage, and he even promised his brother he wouldn’t propose. But Ian was a sun-kissed soccer lover from Brazil, and Meredith was drawn to his who knows what’s next sense of adventure, which was a stark contrast to her more stable runner-up. On the finale, she told Ian she was so in love with him it was crazy. Hey, if there’s ever a time to pick passion over stability, it’s on a TV show where no one expects the love to last anyway.