Ryan Sutter, Season 1
Ryan won us over on day one of the first season. He was tall, dark, and handsome, which was enough, but it turned out he was also a fireman — who wrote poetry. The other guys should’ve just quit the first night. Ryan is now 39, and the athletic hunk is still easy on the eyes. The fact that he and Trista Rehn Sutter have been married for more than 10 years and have two adorable kids together just adds to his hotness. He’s the total package. If he hadn’t been so wonderful, the series probably would’ve stopped right here.