Ali Fedotowsky and Roberto Martinez: The Way They Were! Pre-Breakup [PHOTOS]

The couple insisted things were fine, but quietly announced in October that they were no longer engaged in late October 2011. Still, they kept up all appearances as a happy couple — including another couples trip to Vegas earlier this month! However, this seeming perfect pairing just might not have been meant to be. Ali and Roberto confirmed their split on Monday, November 21. We're still in shock over the news.