Title: Season 5, Episode 9
Air Date: July 13, 2009 at 12:00 AM PDT
Jillian arrives on Maui with the three remaining bachelors (Kiptyn, Ed, and Reid), all of whom she says she loves. At the rose ceremony, after meeting Ed's parents and spending quality time in the fantasy suites with her guys, Jillian lets Reid "Honey Bear" Rosenthal go. (We think this is perhaps the biggest mistake of her life.) She keeps Kiptyn and Ed around — despite concerns about her sexual chemistry with Ed.